Jobs › American Family Insurance
Senior Property Treaty Reinsurance Underwriter (Open to Remote)
Posted Aug 27, 2026 · We last checked this listing on Oct 6, 2026
Apply at American Family Insurance
Likely interview questions for this role
Written from this job description, not a generic list. Each one notes what the interviewer is really checking.
About your past
Tell me about a time you had to decide whether to walk away from a treaty renewal that had been profitable in the past.
What they are checking: willingness to make disciplined decisions against relationship pressure and prior history
Describe a time you had to build trust with a broker or cedent who was skeptical of working with your company.
What they are checking: relationship-building skill and credibility in a market built on broker access
Tell me about the most complex global treaty analysis you've had to present to people who weren't underwriters. How did you make it land?
What they are checking: ability to translate technical findings into decisions non-specialists can act on
Tell me about a time you led a cross-divisional project with competing priorities from different teams. What did you do when people disagreed on approach?
What they are checking: project leadership and ability to manage complexity across stakeholders, not just underwriting skill
What would you do
A broker comes to you with a cedent whose loss history looks clean, but their financial statements show some concerning trends. How do you reconcile that in your recommendation?
What they are checking: ability to weigh conflicting signals across financial and actuarial data rather than relying on one input
If a cedent's exposure concentrations shifted significantly mid-term, how would you approach the conversation with them and any adjustment to terms?
What they are checking: judgment on handling changing risk conditions without damaging the relationship
How would you approach a client audit if you found the cedent's actual claims handling didn't match what was represented in the treaty submission?
What they are checking: integrity and process when compliance gaps surface, and how they balance relationship with accountability
Where's the line for you between authority you can exercise on your own and a decision you'd escalate to your director?
What they are checking: self-awareness about limits, judgment, and comfort operating within a defined authority structure
About the work
Walk me through how you'd evaluate a new property treaty submission from a cedent you've never worked with before. What do you look at first?
What they are checking: whether the candidate has a structured, repeatable underwriting process rather than gut-feel pricing
How do you think about attachment probability and limit exhaustion when you're setting participation levels on a program?
What they are checking: depth of actual technical underwriting knowledge versus surface familiarity with the terms
How do you account for inuring reinsurance and loss trends when you're setting pricing thresholds on a program?
What they are checking: whether the candidate can articulate the mechanics behind a pricing decision, not just the outcome
What global reinsurance market trends are you watching right now, and how are they shaping how you'd underwrite property cat exposure?
What they are checking: currency of market knowledge and strategic awareness beyond day-to-day deal work
Practice this interview out loud.
Offer builds a real interview for this exact role at American Family Insurance from your resume and this job description, asks the questions one at a time, and tells you what landed. The first one is free.
Practice this out loudThe full job description
As published by American Family Insurance.