Jobs › MyPath

Caregiver Supervisor

MyPath · Fort Atkinson, WI · $16.00–$18.00 an hour · Full time

Posted Sep 16, 2026 · We last checked this listing on Oct 6, 2026

Apply at MyPath

Likely interview questions for this role

Written from this job description, not a generic list. Each one notes what the interviewer is really checking.

About your past

Tell me about a time you helped an adult with a disability with personal care. How did you protect their dignity?

What they are checking: Whether they give care respectfully and know how to involve clients in their own care.

Tell me about a time you trained someone new. How did you check that they understood?

What they are checking: Whether they confirm learning rather than assuming it happened.

How do you handle conflict between two caregivers on your team?

What they are checking: Whether they can resolve tension early so it does not affect client care.

Why do you want to step into a supervisor role in residential care?

What they are checking: Whether they want to lead and support others, not just earn a higher rate.

What would you do

As a Direct Support Supervisor you would supervise caregivers and also give personal care. How do you balance both?

What they are checking: Whether they can lead while still doing hands-on work, which this role requires.

A client starts yelling and throwing things in the home. How do you redirect them?

What they are checking: Whether they use calm, positive redirection and keep everyone safe.

How would you coach a caregiver who is doing the minimum and leaving tasks for the next shift?

What they are checking: Whether they can address performance directly while keeping the team working together.

How would you plan a fun outing for clients with different abilities and behaviors?

What they are checking: Whether they think ahead about safety and needs while still making outings enjoyable.

You notice a client seems withdrawn and is not eating. What do you do?

What they are checking: Whether they notice health changes, document them, and report to the right people.

About the work

What does promoting independence look like when helping someone cook or clean?

What they are checking: Whether they let clients do what they can instead of doing tasks for them.

Practice this interview out loud.

Offer builds a real interview for this exact role at MyPath from your resume and this job description, asks the questions one at a time, and tells you what landed. The first one is free.

Practice this out loud

The full job description

As published by MyPath.

Majority Women Employee-Owned. Empowered by Everyone to Transform Lives. Overview Grow with Homes for Independent Living as a Caregiver assisting adult clients with behavioral, medical and/or physical disabilities in a residential home setting. Ensure clients safety, assist clients with daily tasks, be a positive influence chaperoning fun events plus redirect behaviors as needed. HIL is looking for a Direct Support Supervisor (DSS) to join our team. A DSS provides supervision for the direct care support team members. As a Direct Support Supervisor , you will : • Supervise caregiver staff along with training, coaching and mentoring your team. Provide supervision of personnel and client care, enhance the overall health, safety, and welfare of the clients and programming. • Assist client with activities of daily living including physical assistance and personal cares. • Redirect challenging behaviors - Promote independence and quality of life. • Assist with the cooking, cleaning in the home. • All other duties as assigned. Benefits: • Competitive hourly pay $16.00 - $18.00 per hour, plus shift differential, extra $1.00 hr. on 2nd shift AND Extra $2.00 hr. on weekends. Pay based on experience, location and shift. Full-time and part-time hours available. • Set schedules with guaranteed hours, ability to pick up overtime • Wage increases with experience • 4 weeks of PTO every year • $2,000 Referral Bonus Program • Full benefit package, including medical, dental, vision insurance, 401k plan, ESOP and more! Qualifications: • Minimum of 18 years of age • Reliable transportation to and from programs and training classes • Communication & Problem-Solving skills • Successful completion of a caregiver background check, TB test and Health Screen • Valid Driver’s License with 3 years of acceptable driving record, required Additional Information MyPath and its Operating Companies provide specialized services and dignified care for children, adolescents and adults with special needs. Our companies provide a spectrum of services and support which promote the ability of those we serve to live as independently as possible in the community. MyPath is composed of a beautifully diverse spectrum of employees with different characteristics, abilities, and life experiences. We believe that equitable, diverse, and inclusive practices in our workspaces are integral to the existence of MyPath. We value our diverse spectrum of Owners, the individuals we serve and the communities we encounter. Our success as an organization is directly proportional to our ability to create belonging and genuinely engage our Owners and potential Owners. We ask for demographic information so that we can be intentional in supporting our Owners best. Although not required, we would appreciate you sharing to help our commitment of cultivating a diverse, equitable, inclusive, and belonging MyPath. Our Culture At MyPath, we support an ownership culture throughout the organization. Our culture is based on our five beliefs and behaviors: • Passion • Accountability • Teamwork • Openness • Continuous Learning and Innovation As an employee owner, you can expect transparency, respect and appreciation. You’ll impact the place you work and map a career within MyPath. With your passion and our breadth of services, your options are nearly limitless! MyPath is proudly Majority Women Employee-Owned, with women leading at every level from the frontline to the boardroom. Our strength comes from all of us. Every Owner, regardless of gender, plays a vital role in shaping our culture, driving our mission, and building a workplace where opportunity and ownership are shared by all. MyPath is an Equal Opportunity Employer (EOE) committed to fostering a diverse, equitable, and inclusive workplace. We embrace the unique characteristics, abilities, and life experiences of our employees and believe that equitable and inclusive practices are essential to our success. We value the diversity of our Owners, the individuals we serve, and the communities we engage with.

Apply at MyPath